Visit us at Ye Old Goat & Lillians of Appleton!
Menu title
This section doesn’t currently include any content. Add content to this section using the sidebar.
Your headline
Image caption appears here
Add your deal, information or promotional text


















Personalized tray... made to order, just for you! A cute tray to set on a counter to collect loose change and keys or to prop on an easel on a shelf. This is an also a great gift for grandma, grandpa, mom, dad or just about anyone as we can customize it just for you!
*Turnaround time on custom orders is 10 business days.
This tray is made of natural wood -- each piece is unique so there WILL be variations in distressing, wood patterns, knots, dings and dents... all adding to the uniqueness of the piece. Some trays will be slightly lighter/darker in color. All words and designs are engraved into the wood of this tray. Approximate dimensions: 12” x 5” x 0.5”.
Purchase Details:
*Please use the "Add a Note" section at checkout to indicate:
1. _____ Garden (What word would you like before garden? Example says “Grandma” — we can add anything— other examples include Mimi, Nana, Oma, Grammy, Auntie, Mom, Dad, Grandpa or a proper name (Annie’s Garden) — we can add ANY word here.)
2. Birth Month and Corresponding Names (Example: Isla: August, Oliver: April, Penny: December, Johnny: July, Kayla: April) Please triple-check spelling and place in order as you would like them starting from left to right.
*Can fit up to 7 names comfortably— please contact us if you’d like more than 7 names so we can send you a mock-up.
** Tray is customized just for you-- your tray will be available for pick up or shipping 10 business days from when you place your order. If shipping, you should receive your tray 12-17 business days from when you place your order, however, we cannot guarantee ship times. We ship via USPS and while 2-7 days is the typical ship time, we have had ship times up to 3 weeks. Unfortunately, we do not offer refunds based on delayed receipt of your sign once it is in the hands of the USPS.
***All sales are FINAL on custom orders, please ask any questions prior to your purchase. If you would like to see the tray in-person before you purchase, we do have samples available in the store and you are welcome to place your order there if you'd prefer. Points can be earned on custom pieces, but rewards/discounts cannot be used.***
Thank you!! We look forward to serving you!
✨ Local Pickup Option Available ✨
Prefer to pick up your order instead of having it shipped?
Use one of the codes below at checkout and we'll have your order ready for pickup in 3-5 business days.
Use Code:
LILLIANS – pickup at Lillian’s of Appleton
(115 E College Avenue, Appleton)
GOAT – pickup at Ye Old Goat
(1919 E Calumet Street, Appleton)
Simply enter your code at checkout to remove shipping. You will receive an email when your order is ready for pickup at the front counter at whichever location you choose -- usually within 3-5 business days. 🤍
Online Purchase Details: Thank you for choosing The Vintage Garden! Please read over the following details and ask any questions before making your purchase.
In-store Pick Up: Prefer to pick up your order instead of having it shipped?
Use one of the codes below at checkout and we'll have your order ready for pickup in 3-5 business days:
Code: LILLIANS – pickup at Lillian’s, of Appleton (115 E College Avenue, Appleton)
Code: GOAT – pickup at Ye Old Goat (1919 E Calumet Street, Appleton)
Simply enter your code at checkout to remove shipping. You will receive an email when your order is ready for pickup at the front counter at whichever location you choose -- usually within 3-5 business days. 🤍
**Custom signs, handstamped books, and a variety of our other handmade items are made-to-order and have their own timeline as noted. Please watch your email for confirmation on when your item is ready for pick-up.
Shipping: Shipping is calculated by region at a flat rate based on your order total. We ship USPS Mail, which includes insurance. Items will leave our warehouse in Appleton, Wisconsin within 3-5 business days. You will receive an email with tracking information as soon as your items ship.
Return policy: We are aligning our return policy with in-store locations' policies, and all sales are final.
If you are not satisfied with your purchase, please reach out -- we stand by our items and want you to truly love your items!
Thank you again, we look forward to serving you!
Phone/Text: 19204508085
Email: thevintagegarden@yahoo.com