Our Downtown Appleton storefront has closed, but The Vintage Garden continues into two beautiful local locations... plus online as always!
Come shop in-person!
We know there is something spiecal about being able to see, feel and expierence shopping for decor and gifts in-person so we welcome you to visit our booth settings at:
Ye Old Goat
You will find our booths in the first and second rows inside the market.
1919 E Calumet Street, Appleton
{Open 7 Days a Week!}
We are also excited to offer local pickup at this location! If you are local and would prefer to pickup your items instead of having them shipped, simply select 'pick up' at checkout, and we will have your items ready at Ye Old Goat within 2-4 business days -- you will receive an email when your items are ready for pickup.
Coming March 2026, you will also be able to find us at Lillians of Appleton!
115 E College Avenue, Appleton
We have TWO booths at Ye Old Goat! This booth is located in the first row.
We have TWO booths at Ye Old Goat! This booth is located in the second row.
After much prayer and reflection, we’re entering a new season for The Vintage Garden.
Over the past 16 years, life has changed — our family has grown, our children are in new stages, and God has continued to shape our priorities. This transition allows us to be more present with our family while continuing to follow the direction we feel God leading us.
As of early February 2026, we have closed our downtown Appleton storefront and are moving toward pop-ups, vendor markets, and curated booth spaces — while continuing to offer the meaningful décor and gifts you love!
You will be able to continue to shop online with shipping and local pickup options, along with continuing to shop a curated selection of our favorites in person at Ye Old Goat Vintage Market and Lillian's of Appleton (coming March 2026). Be sure to follow along with us to be updated with other pop-ups and markets we will be attending!
We are still here, we’re simply stepping into a new rhythm that honors both family and calling.
We’ll continue sharing where God leads next — including pop-ups, booth locations, and new collections.
“Commit to the Lord whatever you do, and He will establish your plans.” Proverbs 16:3
Frequently asked questions regarding the changes:
If I am local, can I still pick up my order to save on the cost of shipping?
Yes! As always, during checkout online, you can select 'pick up' at Ye Old Goat and you will not be charged for shipping.
Pickup Timeline: Orders will be ready for pick up in 2-4 business days.
We visit Ye Old Goat twice a week (Mondays and Fridays). Any orders placed Monday-Thursday will be available for pickup on Friday afternoon; orders placed Friday-Sunday will be available for pickup on Monday afternoon. You will receive an email when your order is ready for pickup. We ask that orders be picked up within 10 days from receiving pickup email.
How do I use my gift card?
Gift cards can only be redeemed online. If you are local, you are welcome to choose local pickup at checkout to pick your items up at Ye Old Goat to save on shipping. (Gift cards cannot be redeemed at Ye Old Goat or Lillians, sorry.)
Do you still have a rewards program?
While it may be something we add on in the future, at this time, we do not have a rewards program. All previous rewards and points expired on January 31, 2026.
